#Twitter #MMC6612 #doingmyhomework

I can’t help but feel Shepherd’s entire Twitter argument is misguided.

Twitter is, in a lot of ways, a glorified RSS feed. You, as the user, are entirely responsible for what is going to show up in your feed. If you want it to be dispensing up-to-date political and social news, then it’s a pretty simple process to follow (insert your favorite news sources/journalists/hacks) and there you go, that’s the sort of information you’ll receive. If instead, you want superfluous commentary, links to LOLcat pictures, or a reason to immediately stop using Twitter… well then I’m right here.

Shepherd (2009) claimed that Twitter users “are also encouraged to participate instead in the economic cycle of value by shoring up the consumption of celebrity” (p. 154). In my opinion, this statement undermines the user’s control over the information that is being funneled into their feed. As per our assignment, I followed 10 new twitter accounts focused mainly on journalism and social media. And for the last two days, my feed has pretty much been permeated with links to news articles and “how-to” guides focusing on better utilizing Facebook and blogs. Imagine my surprise when I hadn’t received a single Justin Bieber update. Way to let me down, Twitter. (Although to be fair, #Brazil<3JustinBieber is totally trending right now. No, I did not make this up.)

So yeah, Twitter is going to be what you make of it. You can use it to follow and participate in a variety of different dialogues by merely searching for the appropriate accounts, following them, and @replying away. You can use it for microblogging or helping people to find your work. You can use it for figuring out which countries currently ❤ you and which </3 you. You can even do all those things on one account. What a crazy world we live in! But to simply dismiss it as a pretentious form of communication that caters to celebrity culture is shortsighted.

On a slight tangent, I was also somewhat bewildered at the hostile tone Shepherd takes at Twitter and their sinister plans for all my precious tweets. I particularly enjoyed the statement that “the site’s benevolent posturing works to conceal the key function of the ‘for now’ which indicated that Twitter will eventually seek to profit from its user content upon growing further in popularity” (p. 160). How dare they, those benevolent posturing bastards! But seriously, pretty much everyone with a product on the Internet uses Twitter as a free way to advertise and market themselves. It doesn’t seem particularly awful to think that, hey, maybe Twitter should get something too. Shepherd herself makes the point that currently Twitter is operating at a loss. Given that no concrete business model has been suggested that threatens a Twitter user’s generated content specifically, I thought she was being a bit rough on them.


6 Responses to #Twitter #MMC6612 #doingmyhomework

  1. I bet Shephard wants to make money someday. But, she appears to think that Twitter founders should do it out of the goodness of their hearts. I agree with you that she was harsh on them. I’m not sure why she thinks that Twitter should be some sort of public service.

    And then to call Facebook “draconian”? That was overdramatic to me.

  2. joneelauriel says:

    I totally agree with what you’re saying in that the experience you get out of Twitter is what you make it. Like we said in class it’s people that are making #johnankate a trending topic etc. Plenty of political and news content are readily accessible for those that wish to seek it out. So as we further mentioned in class Shepherd was definitely misguided and contradictory in her claims.

  3. Carol says:

    I totally agree with you about “Twitter is going to be what you make of it.” It is not the Twitter itself that is celebrity-centered; it is the users that care about celebrities more than other things. Maybe shepherd focus on celebrities a lot, so she thinks that the “Twitter” is celebrity-centered. I bet there is a lot of people that using Twitter to follow other things, such as news, art, or science.

  4. Excellent: “You, as the user, are entirely responsible for what is going to show up in your feed.” I want to steal that sentence from you and use it over and over.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: